Category: Fabs Lab

  • Focusrite – Midnight EQ

    I will start this Analysis/Review with the description from the Focusrite website:

    ” Focusrite’s new Midnight plug-in suite takes two of the most iconic Focusrite modules of all time – the ISA110 equaliser and ISA130 compressor; models their sound exactly with powerful DSP technology; and gives them elegant, functional on-screen front panels that make them simplicity itself to use. Now you can add that authentic, classic Focusrite sound to your own tracks at a price you can afford. Your productions have never sounded so good.”

    Alright, will this be the case ? proceed to find out…. (more…)

  • SPECIAL – How digital looks like !? (PART 1)

    Here is a quality analysis of Cocko’s ReaComp alongside a comparison to the previous thread of Slate Digital VBC.

    If you are new to the lab post ,read this https://www.gearevu.littlefishaudio.com/must-read-welcome-to-my-lab-updated/

    ReaComp – Settings 

    I’ve tryed to match the VBC & SSL settings

    REAFR%20 %20Copy Edit Content

    FR Reacomp


    REAFR Edit Content

    Well as expected, flat! We need to expect a flat DSC right away

    skiping Reacomp phase sinse its flat.

    THD & THD+N

    THD%20Reac Edit Content

    A great example of digital, one of the cleanest I’ve ever seen actually! But don’t get ahead of your selves this is not how digital behaves, theres more to it, will be covered in part 2!

     
    DSC
     
    DSC Edit Content
     
    Well that was to be expected, sinse the FR is linear.
     
     
     
    THD & THD +N
     
    THD%202 Edit Content
     
    Blue is reacomp & green VBC Grey, Well night and day, quite literaly. It would be more suffircient for a animated graph, but I’ll get to that in part 2.
     
     
    DSC
     
    ASF Edit Content
     
    Here we can see difference very important, in the red is VBC Grey and white Reacomp.
    This shows how a DSC is linked with FR content, Reacomp beeing linear and VBC non linear.
     
    Consensus
     
    One images equals a thousand words, 6 equal more.
     
    Support me by Sharing the Lab posts!
     
    Fab
  • Slate Digital – VBC – FG GREY

    Testing The VBC Pluggins from Slate Digital

    If you are new to the lab post ,read this https://www.gearevu.littlefishaudio.com/must-read-welcome-to-my-lab-updated/

     
    Pic represents settings used for all the tests above

    Frequency Response

    FG%20grey%20FR2 Edit ContentThe test result is pretty strait forward, I think for this one no need to explain. Just in case, this is your ‘EQ curve’

    Phase relationship

    FG%20grey%20phaze Edit Content

    Here we can see the phase rotation of that response, what this means really is that the emulation won’t create undesired phase issues.
    (Emulations that do have undesired phase issues tend to look like an amateur mixer trying to boost and cut everything all together)

    *Note that phase is really dependent on the FR, the more intricate the FR the more chances there will be phase problems.

    THD & THD+N

    FG%20grey%20THD2 Edit Content

    Alright what is this weird thing ? First note that killr in the graph is the analogy of distortion as opposed to no distortion in percent, analogue devices can go from 2% up to 50%. How can you tell just by that if this is analogue? It’s simple in the digital domain what you put in, you get out (as a general rule of thumb). Here though we can see the harmonics created and the noise-floor. The emulation has almost no noise floor. What this graph really tells us, is that the device qualifies as analogue, has a character smooth and rich (in the represented magnitude)! this comes from two observations, the most prominent harmonic is the 2nd order harmonic (2K), which qualifies as smooth and very flattering, yet the harmonic distortion spreads up to 20K which provides us with the ”richness”.

    DSC 

    SC Edit Content

    Well hard knee bend, and a roughness due to the fr, that was to be expected.

    Consensus
    So there you have it, good analogue modeling!

  • Slate Digital – VBC – FG RED

    The plugin is tested on CLA Rock Drive Preset.

    This thread consists of animated graphs shocasing the scaling of the ‘drive’ knob from 0 to 10 in steps of +1

     If you are new to the lab post ,read this https://www.gearevu.littlefishaudio.com/must-read-welcome-to-my-lab-updated/

     

    FR

    QtwghC Edit Content

    Here we can see that the fr changes dependend on the drive level. It scales from a natural almost flat curve with a tiny amount of high end boost to a low shelf like response. Very Interesting and Intricate! Right away we know our DSC will not be linear, because of the behavior of the FR.

    Phaze

    1kianP Edit Content

    Phase rotation is minimal and can be considered nomimal.

    THD/THD+N

    JONdsn Edit Content

    Here is something quite unusual to my experience! The harmonics created in this unit do not exceed the 5th order. This behavior is very unique! but theres more… We can see that by driving the units drive harder, the magnitude of the harmonics is increased in a NON symetrical order! 

    Which makes the drive behavior also modeled!

    You can’t escape agression with this kind of unit behavior.

    ps: Noise is so much low that it’s not even worth mentioning.

    DSC

    cc Edit Content

     

     Well since we are compressing just a little bit, the curve bend won’t seem that drastic

     

    Consensus: This is indeed an intricate agressive true analogue emulation.

     

  • Slate Digital – VBC – FG MU

    In this instance we are going to try something new, instead of messuring the model while compressing, we will messure it with no compression, simply passing the audio through the plugin in its default state. This way we will observe how the analogue emulation behaves on a ‘bypassed’ way!

    Here are the default settings above.

     If you are new to the lab post ,read this https://www.gearevu.littlefishaudio.com/must-read-welcome-to-my-lab-updated/

    FR

    1 Edit Content

    Well thats one hell of a FR, yeap defently not flat 
    I’d say this smacks you right in the face! 
     
    Phaze
     
    2 Edit Content
     
    Looking good and smooth, nothing out of the ordinary.
     
    THD – THD + N
     
    3 Edit Content
     
    This is really interesting! Here we see the unit embends its character just by not beeing used as a compressor, what does this mean ? this unit can be used as a saturation plugin aswell!The order of harmonics here suggest that the saturation character (in the represented magnitude) is Dense because the harmonics 2nd to 5th order have a very small difference in magnitute, still though having the 2nd order hamonic a bit louder has a tubish feel along with all their multyplicates!
     
    Q : But since this can work as a saturation unit, how can I crank up the saturation without without making the unit compress ?
     
    A :Crank the make up gain/volume
     
    Here is the same Graph with the Volume cranked
     
    6 Edit Content
     
    What we see here is nothing like before, 3rd order harmonics are boosted, 2nd order harmonics atenuated. Extreme distortion!
     
    Ps: I use the term harmonics to refer to an order and all its multyplicates.
     
     
    DSC
     
    4 Edit Content
     
    Looks as it should
     
    Q:If I’m saturating, so I must be compressing a little bit right ? The GR metter doesn’t show any compression
     
    A:Yeap compression is happening although the metter does not move, that is because the make up is after the GR in the units architecture.
     
    Bellow you can see how the compression curve looks like with a cranked ”make up”!
     
    dfw Edit Content
     
    Consensus:
     
    This is a true representation of analogue, and a damn good one! (couldn’t resist) 
     
    PS: And remember we haven’t compressed a single db yet! (well not in the traditional way that is )
     
    PS2: Before you go crank the make up on this unit, use a trim plugin after it lowering the overal volum a lot, better safe than sorry 
  • Must Read – Welcome to my Lab! (UPDATED)

    Hi I am Fabian, Music producer and DSP analyst. In this blog I will analyze and review, commercial and non-commercial audio plugins mostly in their analogue modeling accuracy – More about my work and background can be found at: www.prezjaproductions.com

    This by all means will not be your run of the mill review posts, so before you get to the reviews there are a few concepts I need you to understand.

     

    This is not a series of Reviews/Analysis focusing on the subject if something sounds good or not, but rather if the products can be considered analogue modeled, in regard to the generic analogue characteristics & behavior. Putting into test the developer claims.

     

     

     Introduction to our measurements:

    These ‘Graphs’ we will be looking at are called plots; the tool to look at a plot is an FFT analyzer.

    • FR – Frequency Response

     

    FR will be the first test that will provide us with the FR of the unit in question; there will be two types of FR. One will be Frequencies over Magnitude (dB) and Frequencies over Phase (Rotation, FR phase relationships).

     

    • THD & THD+N (True Harmonic Distortion & True Harmonic Distortion + Noise) 

     

    To understand a system with an input and an output, such as an audio amplifier, we start with an ideal system where the transfer function is linear and time-invariant. When a signal passes through a non-ideal, non-linear device, additional content is added at the harmonics of the original frequencies. THD is a measurement of the extent of that distortion.

     

    Simplistic Explanation: This type of measurement shows us if the unit distorts and how it distorts.

     

    •  DSC – Dynamic Static Characteristic

    DSC is the unit’s envelope, and dynamic response. Analogue units do not have a linear dynamic response, they might have near linear FR that will automatically have a near linear DSC. To get a rough idea think of your digital compressor graphs that twist downwards as you increase the ratio. While the former is just a visual representation of the performed setting. DSC is conducted in real time and is the actual envelope representation.

     

    Measurements Interconnections

     While these plots might seem like a series of isolated tests, some -are very connected to each other and some are not. 

    Bellow I will demonstrate the most common relationships:

     Signs to represent the connection =>, <=, <=>

     Example

    • A=>B = A effects b
    • A <=B = B effects A
    • A<=>B = They are interlinked
    • A*<=>B= They are interlinked if a special criteria is met in the implementation of A
    • A<=>B*= They are interlinked if a special criteria is met in the implementation of B

     Common relationships are:

    •  FR<=> DSC: This relationship tends to be one of the strongest it both if FR is pre/post DSC. The more extreme the FR (post DSC) the easier it is for the DSC to look like it has a nonlinear response, this is sort of a false positive while there is a optimal threshold for dsc rougness that can be preserved only when FR is pre DSC, as in analogue units the fr will almost always be pre DSC and the interconnection with DSC is to be expected and logical. In other words, a true analogue envelope response is directly derived from an analogue modeled FR that is pre DSC.
    • DSC<=>FR*: This relationship exists when the dsp module that is related to FR is pre DSC, while  post DSC the FR module does not have this relationship. This is something common in compressors when the units envelope will effect the Fr. This could not happen if the fr is post the envelope.
    • FR=>THD: This relationship in most cases is not strong, it has minimal interaction but it exists.
    • THD*=>FR: In some instances the distortion increase/decrease can interact with the FR.
    • DSC=>THD: This relationship exists both in analogue modeled units, and digital ones.  Sometime domain parameters such as attack/release/hold etc. have an effect on this relationship. It is important to notice that the relationship can be split into three categories, DSC effecting harmonic order relationships and Klirr, DSC effecting only Klirr and DSC being almost autonomous.

     

    I’ll be commenting on the graphs in the reviews so you can really get how the ‘evaluation’ train of thought goes. It is important to read the reviews in chronological order! Not every case will be the same, and the commentary & additional information will differ. That’s why this is very important, since I will take into account this and skip additional explanations if posted in a previous review/analysis, in order to create a texture of understanding & a productive workflow.

     

    FAQ

    Q: Why should I even care about this tech/geeky stuff, my ears tell me all the truth I need to know?

    A: Let me put it simply, these reviews, are data. Data that will help us evaluate the nature of any DSP product. In other words, you’ll know if the juice was worth the squeeze. 

     

     Q: What software/plugins do you use for your measurements ?

    A1: In my private research I use a variety of analyzer software

    Here is a list of these software: 

    • SpectraPLUS – http://www.spectraplus.com/ ( Hardware measurements)
    • Sonic Visualizer – http://www.sonicvisualiser.org/ (General Tasks)
    • Voxengo Span – http://www.voxengo.com/product/spanplus/ (Inside DAW analysis)
    • Christian-W. Budde – VST Analyzer (automated analysis for pluggins )   http://www.savioursofsoul.de/Christian/programs/measurement-programs/

    The lab plots are mainly from Christian-W. Budde – VST Analyzer,  although my version is not the public version.

    Any future lab posts about hardware analysis are from SpectraPLUS.

    Let me make clear that. it is one thing to make a plot and another to read & translate the data properly, this is in fact what I’m doing in my Lab posts.

    I would suggest to wait for the DIY posts, for instructions in these matters. Its is very common to build false impressions if there is no prior extensive experience and knowledge.

     

    All the best

    Fab